Amazon FBA vs Shopify: Fees Compared
Compare the fee structures of Amazon FBA and Shopify side by side to find which platform gives you better margins.
All calculatorsAmazon FBA vs Shopify
Amazon FBA vs Shopify: What's Different?
Amazon and Shopify represent two fundamentally different approaches to selling online. Amazon is a marketplace where you list products alongside millions of other sellers and pay referral fees (8% to 20% depending on category, 15% for most) plus FBA fulfillment fees if you use their warehouses. Shopify is a standalone storefront builder where you pay a flat monthly subscription ($39-$399/mo) plus payment processing fees (2.5-2.9% + $0.30 per transaction) but no per-sale referral fees.
The real cost difference emerges at scale. On Amazon, a seller doing $50,000/month in revenue might pay $5,000-$7,500 in referral fees alone, plus $3-$6 per unit in FBA fees. On Shopify, an operator at the same revenue pays their monthly plan plus roughly 2.9% in payment processing, around $1,450 in transaction fees. However, Shopify operators must drive their own traffic through paid ads, SEO, or social media, which can easily cost thousands per month.
Amazon gives you instant access to 300+ million active customers and handles fulfillment, returns, and customer service through FBA. Shopify gives you full brand control, customer data ownership, and higher margins per sale, but you build your audience from scratch. The right choice depends on whether you value traffic and logistics (Amazon) or brand equity and margin control (Shopify).
Compare Fees on the Same Product
Enter your product details once, see how fees compare on both platforms
Enter Product Details (same product, both platforms)
Amazon FBA
Profit
$9.39
31.3% margin
Shopify
Lower fees+ $39.00/mo subscription (not included in per-sale fees)
Profit
$16.82
56.1% margin
Shopify saves you $7.43 in fees per sale
Estimates are based on item price only. Marketplaces may also apply fees to buyer-paid shipping and tax, and rates vary by category and promotions. Confirm current rates with each marketplace.
Fee Structure Comparison
Which Is Better For...
Best for high-volume commodity sellers
Amazon FBA
If you sell commodity products where brand differentiation is minimal, Amazon's massive built-in audience and FBA logistics make it the clear winner. Customers searching for 'phone charger' or 'yoga mat' default to Amazon. The referral fees are worth paying when you don't need to spend on customer acquisition.
Best for building a recognizable brand
Shopify
Shopify lets you own the entire customer experience: your domain, your design, your email list. If you're building a DTC brand with repeat customers and a strong identity, Shopify's lower per-transaction costs and full data ownership will serve you better long-term than Amazon's marketplace model.
Best for beginners with limited capital
Amazon FBA
New sellers with limited marketing budgets benefit from Amazon's built-in traffic. You don't need to learn Facebook Ads or SEO. Just optimize your listing and Amazon's algorithm does the rest. FBA also eliminates the need for warehouse space. Shopify requires marketing spend from day one to generate sales.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, many successful sellers use both platforms. They sell on Amazon to capture marketplace traffic and use Shopify as their branded storefront. Tools like Shopify's Amazon integration let you sync inventory across both channels. This diversifies revenue and reduces dependence on a single platform.
For a $100 product, Amazon charges roughly $15 in referral fees plus $5-8 in FBA fees, totaling about $20-23 per sale. Shopify charges approximately $2.90 + $0.30 in payment processing, totaling $3.20 per sale. However, you must factor in Shopify's monthly subscription and customer acquisition costs, which can shift the comparison significantly.
No. Amazon does not share customer email addresses with sellers. All communication goes through Amazon's messaging system. This means you cannot build an email list or market directly to past customers. Shopify gives you full access to customer data, enabling email marketing, retargeting, and loyalty programs.
Amazon has established marketplaces in over 20 countries with localized fulfillment through FBA Global. Expanding internationally on Amazon is relatively straightforward. Shopify supports international selling through Shopify Markets, but you handle your own shipping, taxes, and compliance. For ease of international expansion, Amazon has the edge.
Amazon account suspensions can be devastating since you lose access to all your revenue and customer base instantly. Common causes include policy violations, inauthentic product complaints, or metrics falling below standards. Shopify rarely suspends accounts except for selling prohibited items. Diversifying across both platforms reduces this risk.
More Fee Comparisons
Fees are only one leak. Our guide to ecommerce accounting covers COGS, settlements, and the P&L that shows what you actually keep per sale.
Sell on MultiplePlatforms?
Futureproof automatically tracks fees across Amazon FBA, Shopify, and every other marketplace. See unified P&L in one dashboard, part of the AI finance team starting at $1,000/month.
14-day trial · all six agents · starting at $1,000/month