Back to Blog
Inventory & Landed Cost

Warehouse Optimization for Brands That Use a 3PL

Warehouse optimization for brands that use a 3PL: what you control, five numbers to ask for, and how to read the invoice as cost per order.

Oz Merchant14 min read

A brand owner walks a third-party warehouse aisle with the warehouse manager, who points up at a high rack of cartons.

A $35,190 warehouse invoice for September (the invoice is an example), before postage, came to $7.65 for each of 4,600 orders shipped, and about $1,500 of it paid to store products that had almost stopped selling.

Warehouse optimization is the work of storing, picking and shipping goods with less space, labor and error per order. Most of what ranks for the phrase is written for people who run the building. If a 3PL runs your warehouse, you improve it through what you send in and what you keep there, and you keep score in cost per order on its invoice.

The example below makes three changes, worked in full further down:

  • Clear 50 slow products. Saves $1,536 a month in storage and brings in $24,000 from a liquidator; it means facing a write-down of about $56,700 that the stock already owed.
  • Larger, labeled cartons from the factory. Saves about $2,130 a month; the factory has not yet agreed to the bigger carton, and two wholesale buyers order by the case of 24.
  • One location instead of two. Takes $2,850 a month off the invoice; adds about $1,290 of postage, slower West Coast delivery and about $3,950 to move.

Together they take cost per order from $7.65 to $6.20, about $5,200 a month net of the added postage and labels.

What is warehouse optimization?

Warehouse optimization means arranging a warehouse so each order takes less space, time and labor to fill. Inside the building that covers slotting (putting fast sellers nearest the packing stations), pick paths, racking and shelf layout, labor scheduling, receiving routines and the warehouse management system that directs it all. These are the strategies most guides list, and they belong to whoever runs the floor.

Many brands doing $2 million to $20 million a year do not run the floor. Their 3PL decides where products sit and how pickers move, and Amazon does the same inside its fulfillment centers. You cannot re-slot a 3PL's aisles. What you can change is everything that reaches the dock, how long it stays, how many places it sits in, and what each order asks a picker to do. Those choices land on the invoice every month.

What you control when a 3PL runs the warehouse

Four sets of choices sit with you, not the 3PL. The table shows where each one appears on the bill, using the example company's contract. Rate names and structures differ between 3PLs, so read your own rate card alongside it.

Your choiceWhat it changes in the warehouseWhere it shows on the invoice
Carton and pallet configuration from the supplierHow many cartons are received and how densely pallets stackReceiving, pallet storage
Labels and paperwork on inbound stockWhether cartons can be scanned in, or must be counted and labeled by handReceiving, special projects
How many products you carry, and how slow the tail isHow many pallets and pick locations you pay forStorage
How many locations you split stock acrossDuplicate pick locations, transfers between sites, extra account feesStorage, transfers, account fees
Order shape: units per order, bundles, insertsHow much picking and packing each order needsPick and pack, packaging

Pick and pack is the biggest line on the example invoice, and the one you can move least, because it follows the number of orders. The lines that respond to your decisions are storage, receiving and the special projects that appear when stock arrives in a state the 3PL cannot use.

Read the 3PL invoice as the scoreboard

A 3PL invoice can run to dozens of lines. Group them into five buckets and divide by orders shipped, and the month becomes one number with a short explanation. How to read every line of the invoice is covered in 3PL costs; here the point is what the totals say about your choices.

The company in this example sells towels, bedding and throws, about $8 million a year, from a 3PL with two locations, while Amazon ships its Amazon orders. Its rates are invented for this post; replace them with your own contract's:

RateExample contract
Pallet storage$24 per pallet per month
Pick location (shelf or bin)$6 per location per month
Receiving$3 per carton, or $10 per full pallet
Pick and pack$3.00 for the first unit, $0.75 for each additional unit
Packaging materials$0.55 per order
Wholesale$1.50 per carton picked, $15 per pallet built
Transfer between locations$1.50 per carton, freight billed at cost
Special projects$0.35 per unit labeled, $45 per hour of labor
Account fee$250 per location per month

September's invoice, before postage:

Invoice lineActivityAmount
Pallet storage300 pallets × $24$7,200
Pick locations340 locations × $6$2,040
Receiving1,100 cartons × $3$3,300
Pick and pack, first unit4,600 orders × $3.00$13,800
Pick and pack, additional units2,760 units × $0.75$2,070
Packaging4,600 orders × $0.55$2,530
Wholesale420 cartons × $1.50 + 22 pallets × $15$960
Transfer east to west200 cartons × $1.50 + $1,100 freight$1,400
Special projects3,200 units labeled × $0.35 + 6 hours × $45$1,390
Account fees2 locations × $250$500
Total before postage$35,190

Grouped, that is $9,240 of storage (26%), $19,360 of order handling including wholesale and packaging (55%), $3,300 of receiving (9%), $2,790 of transfers and special projects (8%) and $500 of fees (1%). Postage for the 4,600 orders, about $41,900, is passed through on the same invoice and is left out of this exercise, because carrier choice and rates are a separate decision.

$35,190 ÷ 4,600 orders = $7.65 per order. It is a blunt number, since wholesale and storage for stock bound for Amazon sit inside it, but it is the one to track month to month. Against an average order value of about $58 it is 13% of each order before postage. When cost per order rises while orders hold steady, one of the four sets of choices above has usually moved, and the buckets show which.

Five numbers to ask your 3PL for each month

The invoice says what you paid. These five say why. Three come from the 3PL, one you can work out from its order file, and one you calculate yourself. The stock file, adjustment log and returns report that keep counts honest are listed in inventory accuracy; these are the numbers that explain cost.

NumberHow it is definedWhat it tells youA reading to question
Receiving timeHours or days from a delivery arriving to the units being available to sell, by receiptHow long stock you have paid for sits unsellableReceipts that run past the time in the contract, or slower every month
Pick accuracyOrders shipped with no wrong or missing item ÷ orders shipped, with the list of errorsWhat mis-picks cost in reshipments and returns, and whether stock records are drifting by productErrors clustered on products that look alike, which often points to labels or packaging you control
Storage by productPallets and pick locations each product occupied at month endWhich products the storage line is paying forProducts whose storage per unit sold is a large share of their margin
Units per orderUnits shipped ÷ orders shippedHow much of pick and pack is charged per order rather than per unitA falling figure after a bundle or promotion change
Cost per orderInvoice total before postage ÷ orders shippedThe scoreboardRising while orders are flat

Storage by product may not be in your 3PL's standard monthly reports, and it is the most useful of the five. Divide each product's monthly storage by the units it sold. In September one of the example company's throws, which sells for $49 and costs $14 to land, held a pallet and a pick location, $30 of storage, and sold 4 units: $7.50 of storage for each unit sold, before anyone picks it. A fast-selling bath towel on the same rate card works out to a few cents. Ask for the file as of the last day of the month, in pallets and locations by product, so it ties to the storage line on the invoice.

Units per order explains the pick and pack line. In September the company shipped 7,360 units in 4,600 orders, 1.6 units an order. Pick and pack came to $15,870, about $3.45 an order or $2.16 a unit. Because the first unit carries most of the charge, anything that adds a unit to an order, such as a bath sheet and hand towel sold as a set, spreads the per-order charge across more revenue.

A worked example: three changes to one month's bill

The example company makes three changes over the fall and wants to know what each one does to the invoice, to cost per order and to cash. The volumes stay at September's: 4,600 orders, 7,360 units, the same wholesale activity.

1. Clearing slow products

Sixty products sold fewer than ten units each in September. Fifty of them can go; the other ten are parts of sets that still sell. The fifty sit on 44 pallets (36 in the east location, 8 in the west) and 80 pick locations (50 east, 30 west), and carry $80,000 at cost. A liquidator offers $24,000 for the lot.

LineMonthly
Pallet storage, 44 × $24$1,056
Pick locations, 80 × $6$480
Storage saved$1,536
One-off: 44 pallets out × $15$660

Held for a year, those products would cost about $18,400 in storage alone, plus the cost of $24,000 of cash that stays on a shelf instead of in the bank: about $2,200 more at a 9% borrowing rate. That is roughly $20,600 a year to keep stock the market values at $24,000 today. Clearing turns it into cash and takes $1,536 off every invoice from then on, about $0.33 per order.

The accounting does not wait for the decision. If the company takes the offer, the value to use is $24,000 less the $660 to pull the pallets, so the write-down is about $56,700, in the month that became clear. If it keeps selling, the value is what the products will fetch in normal sales less selling costs; the offer is evidence, not the answer, and your CPA makes the call.

This is why brands keep paying to store dead stock: nobody wants a $56,700 hit in one month. The loss already happened when the stock stopped selling; holding it only adds $1,536 a month to it. The full exit options are in dead stock, and the entries in inventory write-offs.

2. Changing case packs and labels

The company's top 15 products arrive 24 units to a carton, mixed in cartons, with no barcode on the outside, so the 3PL counts them by hand. Some also arrive without a barcode on the unit: 3,200 units in September, which the 3PL labeled. That month brought 900 cartons from suppliers, 600 of them for those 15 products, plus $1,390 of special projects.

The company asks the factory to pack those products 48 to a carton, one product per carton, with a barcode label on each carton and each unit. The factory quotes $0.05 a unit for the labels, about $160 a month on September's 3,200 labeled units, which goes into the landed cost of the goods (the factory price plus freight and duty).

LineBeforeAfterChange
Receiving, supplier cartons900 × $3 = $2,700600 × $3 = $1,800−$900
Special projects$1,390$0−$1,390
Factory labels, in product cost$0$160+$160
Net monthly effect−$2,130

The factory has agreed to the labels but not yet to the larger carton, which changes its own carton supply and pallet plan. If it declines, the receiving saving goes and the change is worth about $1,230 a month rather than $2,130. Two of the company's wholesale buyers also order these products by the case of 24, so the 3PL would have to split cartons for them at a charge, a cost to price before signing off. Check, too, that a 48-unit carton stays light enough for your 3PL and carriers to handle as a standard carton.

3. Consolidating two locations into one

The west location was opened to reach West Coast customers faster. It ships about 20% of orders and is stocked by transfers from the east. After the clearance it holds 62 pallets and 100 pick locations, all for products that also have a pick location in the east.

LineMonthly saving
Duplicate pick locations, 100 × $6$600
Second account fee$250
Transfer handling and freight$1,400
Receiving transferred cartons, 200 × $3$600
Total off the invoice$2,850

The pallets move rather than disappear, so pallet storage does not change. Two costs sit outside the invoice. Postage rises for the roughly 920 West Coast orders a month that now ship farther; at about $1.40 more an order on the company's carrier rates, that is about $1,290 a month. Delivery may also take a day or two longer for those customers, which the invoice will never show and which may cost sales. The move itself is a one-off: 62 pallets out at $15 ($930), a freight quote of $2,400 and 62 pallets received at $10 ($620), about $3,950.

Moves between warehouses are where stock goes missing or sits unsellable. Count before the move and after it, and plan it outside the busy season.

The bill before and after

Invoice lineSeptemberAfter all three changes
Pallet storage$7,200$6,144 (256 pallets)
Pick locations$2,040$960 (160 locations)
Receiving$3,300$1,800 (600 cartons)
Pick and pack$15,870$15,870
Packaging$2,530$2,530
Wholesale$960$960
Transfers$1,400$0
Special projects$1,390$0
Account fees$500$250
Total before postage$35,190$28,514
Cost per order$7.65$6.20

The invoice falls by $6,676 a month. Take off the $1,290 of extra postage and the $160 of factory labels and the net effect is about $5,200 a month, or about $63,000 a year under these assumptions, for one-off costs of about $4,600 ($660 to clear, $3,950 to move). In cost per order the invoice drops $1.45, of which about $0.31 comes back through postage and labels.

Notice what did not change: pick and pack, the biggest line, stayed at $15,870. Every saving came from storage, receiving, transfers and projects, the lines that follow what you send and what you keep.

How warehouse costs land in the accounts

Storage, picking and shipping are costs of the month, not part of what the stock cost, and they come off contribution margin as they are incurred. Factory labels and carton changes are part of what the stock cost and reach cost of goods sold when the units sell. Relabeling to fix a supplier's mistake is an expense of the month, not inventory cost. Where receiving and transfers go is a one-time call to agree with your CPA; 3PL costs sets out the choices.

Amazon is a warehouse you do not run either

The same logic applies to stock at Amazon, with fewer levers. Amazon charges storage monthly on the space your inventory occupies, measured in cubic feet, adds an aged inventory charge for items stored in a fulfillment center for more than 181 days, and sets fulfillment fees by the product's price, weight and dimensions, according to its FBA page. Check the current rates there before modeling. What you send in and how long it stays are still the controls; how both show up as carrying cost is worked through in inventory carrying cost.

Keep score in cost per order

For a brand that does not run its own warehouse, warehouse optimization is decided at the factory, in the product range and in where stock sits, and it shows up on the 3PL invoice. Divide the invoice by orders each month, ask for storage by product, and change what you send before you ask the 3PL for a lower rate. In the example, three such changes took cost per order from $7.65 to $6.20 without touching the largest line on the bill.

FAQ

What is a good cost per order at a 3PL?

There is no reliable public benchmark, because contracts, products and order sizes differ too much to compare. The useful comparisons are your own trend and like-for-like quotes. Divide the monthly invoice before postage by orders shipped, track it every month, and when you request quotes from other 3PLs, price your actual September volumes on each rate card rather than comparing headline rates.

When is it worth switching 3PLs?

Switch when the problems are the 3PL's own, such as receiving that runs past the contract, recurring pick errors or counts that will not tie out, and fixing what you send in has not helped. A move carries one-off fees, freight and weeks when some stock cannot be sold, so price those against the monthly saving and schedule the move outside your busiest season.

How do you improve warehouse efficiency without running the warehouse?

Change what reaches the dock and what stays there. Ask suppliers for single-product cartons with scannable labels, clear products whose storage per unit sold eats their margin, avoid splitting stock across more locations than delivery speed justifies, and sell sets that add units to each order. Then watch cost per order on the 3PL invoice to confirm each change worked.

See the whole platform

Reading it is one thing. Running it is another.

Book a demo for an overview of the whole platform.

Margin Matters

The ecommerce news, read for your margin

Twice a month: the changes that touch your P&L, the money behind each one, and one move to make. Three minutes, then back to work.

Twice a month. Unsubscribe anytime.