At an illustrative dog-bed maker with about $9 million a year in sales, August came in on plan, yet gross margin fell from 52% to 50%. The cause is one line: a write-down of about $15,000 on a discontinued sage bed, with 2,130 of them still at the 3PL and at Amazon. Not one bed has been thrown away. So why is there a loss on August's P&L for stock that has not sold?
Because stock is worth what it will bring back, not what it cost. Once it is clear a product will sell for less than its cost after the costs to sell it, the shortfall is a loss in that month, sold or not. That entry is a write-down. An inventory write-off removes stock that is gone or worth nothing: lost, damaged, expired, destroyed or donated. Clearing dead stock is covered in dead stock; this post is about booking it.
Inventory write-off vs write-down: the difference
A write-down asks: will this stock still sell for at least what it cost? A write-off asks: does this stock still exist in a sellable form?
| Write-down | Write-off | |
|---|---|---|
| What happened | Stock will sell for less than its cost, after the costs to sell it | Stock is gone or worthless |
| Typical causes | Discontinued colorway, price test failed, season ended, a wholesale buyer pulled the line | Lost or damaged at a 3PL or Amazon, expired, destroyed, donated, unexplained shrink |
| Units on the books | Stay, at a lower cost each | Removed |
| Amount | Cost less what each unit will net | Full cost of the units |
| When | The month it becomes clear the stock will sell for less | The month the loss happens, or when it is found if the date cannot be known |
Size does not decide which entry applies. A pallet crushed by a forklift is written off even if the bed sells at full price that week; a bed that nets $25 against a $32 cost is written down though none is damaged.
When an inventory write-down is due
For a brand on FIFO or average cost, stock is carried at the lower of two figures: what it cost to land, and what it will sell for after the costs needed to sell it. That second figure is called net realizable value. The costs to sell include marketplace fees, payment fees, fulfillment and shipping, and any disposal cost. Cost here means landed cost.
The test is usually run product by product, which is the safest way; the CPA decides if any grouping is acceptable. It runs at each month end. A write-down is due in the month it becomes clear that a product will sell for less than its cost. That is true whether or not anyone has decided to clear the stock. Holding the stock and hoping does not avoid the entry; it only moves the loss to a later month, distorts that month's margin, and overstates inventory on the balance sheet until then.
The usual evidence:
- A price test showing the best price the product can fetch, after fees and shipping, is below cost.
- The product is discontinued and a replacement is live on the same listings.
- A wholesale buyer drops the line or will only take it back at a markdown.
- Stock older than six months is growing in the aged stock report, the early warning set out in inventory KPIs. That alone is not evidence; it is the reason to run the price test now.
Two rules follow from this. First, the write-down is an estimate, redone every month end; if the price the product can fetch keeps falling, the write-down grows. Second, once a financial year has closed, the written-down amount becomes the new cost and is not written back up if prices recover. If the write-down was booked earlier in the same year and the price recovers before year end, the units are written back up, but never above what they originally cost.
The inventory write-off journal entry, in plain words
Each entry takes value out of inventory and puts the same amount on the P&L as a cost. The journal entries below use the worked example's figures.
| Event | Debit (cost goes here) | Credit (comes out of here) | Example amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Write-down to what the stock will net | Cost of goods sold: inventory write-downs | Inventory | $14,910 |
| Sale of a written-down unit | Cost of goods sold | Inventory | $25 a unit, the reduced cost |
| Units lost or damaged at Amazon or a 3PL | Cost of goods sold: inventory losses | Inventory | $1,000 |
| Reimbursement for those units, once approved or probable | Amazon or 3PL receivable | Inventory loss recoveries, next to the losses in cost of goods sold | $720 |
| Damaged units found and written off | Cost of goods sold: inventory losses | Inventory | $2,250 |
| Further write-down when a liquidator's offer is accepted | Cost of goods sold: inventory write-downs | Inventory | $18,000 |
| Units sold to the liquidator | Cost of goods sold | Inventory | $27,000 |
A write-down moves the shortfall per unit from the balance sheet to the P&L; a write-off moves the whole cost. Good stock given to charity, rather than damaged stock, comes off at its cost to a donations expense outside cost of goods.
Some brands credit an inventory reserve account instead of inventory; the P&L effect is the same. Either way, keep write-downs in an account of their own so gross margin can be read before and after them.
Where it shows on the P&L and what it does to gross margin
Normal, expected write-downs and write-offs usually sit inside cost of goods sold, so they come straight off gross margin. A large, unusual one, say a whole product line written down after a recall, may be shown on its own line so it does not distort the trend. Practice varies, and the CPA decides where the line sits in the financial statements.
Either way, the margin effect is immediate. The dog-bed maker runs about $750,000 of net revenue a month at a 52% gross margin, so $390,000 of gross profit. The $14,910 write-down takes that to $375,090, or 50.0%. Read without the write-down line, August looks like a pricing problem that does not exist.
Cash is a separate story. The write-down moves no money. The cash left months earlier, when the beds were paid for.
Worked example: one dog bed from slow to liquidated
The dog-bed maker from the opening values stock on FIFO. Its roll-packed orthopedic dog bed in a sage fabric, which ships in a standard box, sold steadily at $89 until a new fabric launched on the same listings in July. On June 30 it held 2,400 sage beds at a landed cost of $32 each, $76,800 of stock.
Selling one bed at $89 costs about $26 in marketplace and payment fees, fulfillment and shipping. Part of that is a percentage of the price, so at $45 the cost to sell is about $20.
July: slow, and no entry
Sales of the sage bed drop from about 300 a month to 120, all still at $89. Revenue is $10,680 and cost of goods is $3,840 (120 × $32). Each bed still nets $63 ($89 less $26), well above the $32 cost. No write-down is due, however slow the product looks. Closing stock is 2,280 beds, $72,960.
August: written down
The company tests prices through the month and finds $45 is the best the sage bed will fetch now that the new fabric sits beside it. It sells 150 at that price: revenue $6,750, cost of goods $4,800 (150 × $32).
At $45 each bed nets $25 ($45 less $20), $7 below its $32 cost. That became clear in August, so the write-down belongs in August, on all 2,130 beds still on hand: 2,130 × $7 = $14,910. Nobody has decided to liquidate, and it does not matter. The estimate has to cover every bed on hand, so if $45 will only move a few hundred a month, the rest are priced at what they are expected to clear for; for now the company judges $45 will clear them. Closing stock is 2,130 beds at $25 each, $53,250.
September: the written-down stock sells
It sells 200 more at $45. Revenue is $9,000 and cost of goods is $5,000, at the reduced $25 a bed, not the original $32. Gross profit on the bed is $4,000, which the $20 a unit cost to sell takes to zero. The loss was counted once, in August.
Suppose a wholesale account had offered $60 a bed in September instead. The beds sold to that account would show the higher margin in September. If $60 had become the price the remaining beds could fetch, they would be written back up in September, to no more than $32, because it is still the same year.
Closing stock is 1,930 beds, $48,250.
October: liquidated, lost and donated
Early in the month the company has Amazon send its remaining sage beds back to the 3PL; the removal charge is a cost of clearing the stock, booked in October. Then three things happen, each recorded separately.
- A liquidator offers $15 a bed for 1,800 beds, and the company accepts. The $15 is below the $25 the beds were carried at, so the extra $10 a bed, $18,000, is booked as a further write-down when the offer is accepted. If the offer, or clear signs of it, had arrived before September's books were closed, that write-down would belong in September. The liquidator then collects the beds from the 3PL, which charges to pull and load them. Revenue is $27,000 and cost of goods is $27,000 (1,800 × $15). The liquidator agreed not to resell on Amazon or eBay. Without that, clearance beds can turn up on the company's own listings below the new fabric's price.
- Amazon reports 40 beds lost in its fulfillment centers this month. They are written off at $25 each, $1,000.
- Ninety beds turned up with torn covers when the 3PL pulled the liquidator's order, and cannot be sold. They are written off to inventory losses at $25 each, $2,250, in the month the damage is found. They are then donated to an animal shelter, which moves nothing more. The 3PL disputes that the covers tore in its care, so there is no claim to book; the $2,250 stays a loss.
Every one of the 2,400 beds is now accounted for:
| Sage beds | Units |
|---|---|
| On hand, June 30 | 2,400 |
| Sold July to September, at $89 then $45 | −470 |
| Sold to the liquidator | −1,800 |
| Lost at Amazon, written off | −40 |
| Found torn at the 3PL, written off, then donated | −90 |
| On hand, October 31 | 0 |
November: the reimbursement
Amazon approves a claim for the 40 lost beds and pays $720. That is booked in November as its own entry, not netted back into October's write-off. The reimbursement is not a sale. It goes to an inventory loss recoveries line next to the losses in cost of goods, and any part above the cost written off waits until Amazon approves it.
The four months in one table
| Month | Beds sold | Revenue | Cost of goods sold | Write-down or write-off | Gross profit | Closing beds | Closing stock at cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| July | 120 | $10,680 | $3,840 | $0 | $6,840 | 2,280 | $72,960 |
| August | 150 | $6,750 | $4,800 | $14,910 | −$12,960 | 2,130 | $53,250 |
| September | 200 | $9,000 | $5,000 | $0 | $4,000 | 1,930 | $48,250 |
| October | 1,800 | $27,000 | $27,000 | $21,250 | −$21,250 | 0 | $0 |
| Total | 2,270 | $53,430 | $40,640 | $36,160 | −$23,370 |
Cost of goods of $40,640 plus write-downs and write-offs of $36,160 is $76,800, every dollar paid for the 2,400 beds. Revenue of $53,430 less that $76,800 is the $23,370 gross loss on the product before the $720 reimbursement and before the costs of selling it.
Without the write-downs, August would have shown $1,950 of gross profit on the bed and October a $34,760 gross loss. With them, each loss shows up in the month it became known, which is the month a CEO can still act on it.
Units lost or damaged at a 3PL or Amazon
Units lost, damaged or destroyed at a 3PL or Amazon come off inventory at cost in the month the loss happens. When the date cannot be known, as with units that simply fail to appear in a count, they come off when the difference is found. How to work a count against the ledger, location by location, is in ecommerce inventory management, and why counts drift at 3PLs and Amazon in inventory accuracy.
A reimbursement is a separate event. It is booked when the claim is approved, or when payment is probable, and not before. Netting an expected reimbursement against the loss early makes the month look better than it was. How Amazon's reimbursements arrive in settlements is covered in Amazon FBA accounting, and how to audit what Amazon owes in the Amazon reimbursements guide.
Stock shipped to Amazon and not yet checked in stays in inventory. If the shipment closes short or the evidence shows units were lost on the way, they come off then, and any claim is booked separately once approved or probable.
Donation and disposal
Stock that is damaged or worthless is written off to inventory losses inside cost of goods when the damage is found, and donating it afterwards moves nothing more. Good stock given to charity comes off at its cost to a donations expense outside cost of goods, and creates no revenue.
Destroying stock works the same way, with one addition: the cost of disposal is an expense in the month it is incurred. Amazon can return, dispose of or liquidate inventory held in its fulfillment centers for a per-item charge, and it charges monthly for items stored in a fulfillment center for more than 181 days, according to Amazon's FBA page. Weigh them against the cost of holding, set out in inventory carrying cost.
Inventory write-off tax deduction: the US basics
The tax return and the books do not always agree on inventory, and a book write-down is not automatically a tax deduction in the same year. As a general rule, a deduction needs the stock to be sold, scrapped, donated or actually offered for sale at the lower price.
IRS Publication 538 says a few things worth knowing:
- Goods that cannot be sold at normal prices "because of damage, imperfections, shop wear, changes of style, odd or broken lots, or other similar causes" should be valued "at their bona fide selling price minus direct cost of disposition."
- "When you offer merchandise for sale at a price lower than market in the normal course of business, you can value the inventory at the lower price, minus the direct cost of disposition." Those prices come from actual sales "for a reasonable period before and after the date of your inventory."
- Under the lower of cost or market method, "you must value each item in the inventory separately," and the method does not apply to goods accounted for under LIFO.
- A casualty or theft loss of inventory is usually claimed through a higher cost of goods sold, and then "any insurance or other reimbursement you receive for the loss is taxable." If the loss is claimed separately instead, the publication says to reduce it by the reimbursement received or expected.
- For normal goods, "market" means "the usual bid price on the date of inventory," based on the volume the business usually buys. That is closer to what it would cost to buy the stock again than to what it will sell for, so the tax test and the book test can give different answers.
The publication also sets out an exception for small business taxpayers, which it describes as those with "average annual gross receipts of $26 million or less (indexed for inflation) for the 3 prior tax years" that are not tax shelters. A brand the size of the one in this example may qualify, which can change the answer. For goods that cannot be sold at normal prices, the publication points to Regulations section 1.471-2(c), which has its own conditions on when a lower value is allowed; the CPA confirms them. Donations of inventory are treated differently depending on whether the brand is a C corporation, an S corporation, a partnership or a sole proprietorship. Take all of this to the CPA before year end, along with the dates and evidence for each write-down and write-off: the price tests, the liquidator's offer, the donation receipt, the 3PL's loss report.
A month-end check for write-downs and write-offs
Three checks keep each loss in the month it belongs to:
- For each product over six months old in the aged stock report, note the best price it can fetch now and what it costs to sell at that price, product by product unless the CPA accepts a grouping.
- Book any write-down in the month the evidence arrives, to its own account, normally inside cost of goods sold; the CPA may show a large, unusual one on its own line.
- Book losses at Amazon and the 3PL in the month they happen, or when found if the date cannot be known, and reimbursements only once approved or probable.
Stock that has not sold can still put a loss on this month's P&L. The month it becomes clear a product will bring back less than it cost, the shortfall belongs to that month. Booked then, gross margin stays one you can trust, instead of one large surprise at the year-end count, the problem set out in perpetual vs periodic inventory.
FAQ
What is the journal entry to write off inventory?
Debit an expense account, usually an inventory losses account inside cost of goods sold, and credit inventory for the cost of the units removed. For 40 units lost at Amazon with a cost of $25 each, that is a $1,000 debit to inventory losses and a $1,000 credit to inventory. Any reimbursement is booked separately once it is approved or probable.
Can an inventory write-down be reversed?
Once a financial year has closed, the written-down amount becomes the new cost and is not written back up if prices recover. If the write-down was booked earlier in the same year and the price recovers before year end, the units are written back up, but never above what they originally cost. When written-down stock sells, cost of goods sold is the reduced amount.
Is an inventory write-off tax deductible?
Often, but the timing can differ from the books. A tax deduction generally needs the stock to be sold, scrapped, donated or offered for sale at the lower price, and IRS Publication 538 sets out how inventory that cannot be sold at normal prices is valued. Donation rules differ by entity type, so your CPA should confirm the treatment before year end.



