The December count came in $74,000 below the inventory on the balance sheet. For this brand, a hypothetical maker of dog beds and travel crates, the gap goes into December's cost of goods, and a month running at the estimated 63% gross margin shows 56%. Nobody can say which product it came from, which warehouse, or which month it belonged to.
That brand runs periodic inventory, and never chose to. Perpetual inventory updates stock and cost of goods with every receipt and every sale; periodic updates them only when the stock is counted. The label matters less than how often the accounts learn what the stock did. Periodic counted product by product every month gets close to perpetual. A percentage of sales trued up once a year produces the $74,000 December.
What is a perpetual inventory system?
A perpetual inventory system keeps a running record of every unit on hand and what each one cost. A receipt from the factory adds units at landed cost. A sale takes units out and records their cost as cost of goods sold in the same month the sale is recorded. A return, a transfer between warehouses or a lost unit moves the record too. At any month end, the inventory balance on the balance sheet is what the record says should be on hand.
Landed cost here means the factory price plus the freight, duty and other costs it took to get the stock to where it sells. The full list is in what landed cost is.
What is a periodic inventory system?
A periodic inventory system leaves the inventory balance alone between counts. Purchases go to a purchases account when the brand takes ownership, which under many factory terms is when the goods ship, not when they arrive. At each count, cost of goods sold for the period comes from one formula:
Cost of goods sold = beginning inventory + purchases − ending inventory
Between counts, cost of goods is either left out or estimated, often as a flat percentage of sales. How good periodic numbers are depends on how often the count happens and whether it is taken product by product.
The difference between perpetual and periodic inventory
The difference is when the accounts learn what happened to the stock. Perpetual records each movement it is told about as it happens. A loss nobody records shows up only when a count or a claim surfaces it, and the date of some losses can never be known. Periodic learns at the count, so anything that went missing since the last one is mixed in with what sold. Both can use FIFO, LIFO or weighted average. Under FIFO, with accurate counts, a full year lands at the same total either way; under LIFO or average cost the two can differ, because the cost is worked out at each sale instead of once at the count.
Perpetual vs periodic inventory, side by side
| Perpetual | Periodic | |
|---|---|---|
| When inventory is updated | Every receipt, sale, return, transfer and adjustment | At each count |
| How cost of goods is found | Units sold × their cost, as each sale is recorded | Beginning inventory + purchases − ending inventory |
| Margin by product and channel | In the accounts every month | In the accounts, by product when each product is counted and by channel not at all; outside them, only at a unit cost someone keeps up by hand |
| Lost, damaged or stolen units | A separate adjustment when found | Inside cost of goods |
| What the count does | Checks the record and corrects it | Creates the number |
| Effort to run | Every receipt costed, every sale costed | One count and one calculation per period |
| Fits | Several locations, several channels, many products | A small catalog in one location, counted by product every month |
A perpetual inventory example: one month worked both ways
The same brand sells through Shopify, Amazon and a few dozen independent pet stores. Here is one product, an orthopedic dog bed, through October 2026.
- On October 1 the brand owns 2,000 beds at a landed cost of $40 each: $80,000.
- On October 14 a container lands with 3,000 more. The factory charged $31 a bed, and freight, duty and drayage add $9, so they land at $40: $120,000.
- In October it sells 2,600 beds across the three channels at an average of $105 after discounts: $273,000 of revenue.
- On October 31 the 3PL's count finds 1,640 beds and Amazon's report shows 700. That is 2,340 beds, worth $93,600.
The record says there should be 2,400 beds (2,000 + 3,000 − 2,600). Sixty are missing: 40 the 3PL cannot find, and 20 that Amazon reports damaged in its warehouse. Whether the 3PL pays for its 40 depends on its contract, and where they went may never be known.
The month under perpetual
Each sale takes its cost when it is recorded: 2,600 beds × $40 = $104,000 of cost of goods. The 60 missing beds come off inventory through a separate adjustment of $2,400, booked in October because that is when the loss was found. If Amazon approves a reimbursement for the 20 damaged beds, that is booked on its own when approved or when payment is probable, not netted against the loss in advance.
The month under periodic, counted by product
Cost of goods is beginning inventory plus purchases less the count: $80,000 + $120,000 − $93,600 = $106,400. That matches perpetual's $104,000 plus $2,400, and because the count was taken by product, the bed's margin is right. What it cannot separate is the $2,400 of missing beds from the cost of beds sold, so the P&L shows margin slipping without saying why.
The month under periodic, estimated
Many smaller brands do not count monthly. They book cost of goods at a planned rate, in this case 37% of sales, set from last year's costs, and wait for the next count. That gives $101,010 of cost of goods, and the balance sheet carries the difference as inventory that does not exist.
| October, orthopedic dog bed | Perpetual | Periodic, counted | Periodic, estimated |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $273,000 | $273,000 | $273,000 |
| Cost of goods sold | $104,000 | $106,400 | $101,010 |
| Inventory loss, separate line | $2,400 | Inside cost of goods | Not yet known |
| Gross profit | $166,600 | $166,600 | $171,990 |
| Gross margin | 61.0% | 61.0% | 63.0% |
| Inventory at October 31 | $93,600 | $93,600 | $98,990 |
The estimated column overstates the month's gross profit by $5,390. Of that, $2,400 is the missing beds and $2,990 is the rise in landed cost that last year's rate did not know about, since the beds really cost 38.1% of sales this October. The arithmetic in the third column is right; the inputs are a guess.
Pros and cons of each system
Perpetual inventory
The case for perpetual is information. Every month shows cost of goods, margin by product and by channel, and a list of what went missing and where, once a count or a claim surfaces it. Figures like days of inventory and GMROI can be trusted monthly, and each count's differences are dated to the month they were found.
The cost is discipline: every receipt, sale, return, transfer and loss has to be recorded at cost. It also needs inventory software connected to the accounting system, because a spreadsheet struggles to keep up across three channels.
Periodic inventory
The case for periodic is simplicity. A brand with a small catalog in one warehouse, selling mainly through one channel and counting product by product every month, gets a fair cost of goods and fair product margins with little effort and no inventory software. For that brand periodic is a reasonable choice, and many brands start there.
What it shows depends on the count. Counted monthly by product, it gives product margins with losses folded in. Counted once a year with an estimate in between, cost of goods is one approximate number for eleven months; any margin by product lives in a spreadsheet or a profit tool, at a cost per unit nobody checks against the count, and the correction grows with the time between counts.
Many small brands run periodic without knowing it
Ask a CEO whether their company runs perpetual or periodic and many will not know. Look instead at how cost of goods gets into the accounts. If the bookkeeper takes a percentage of sales each month, or plugs a figure from an operations spreadsheet, and the real number arrives with a count at year end, it is periodic with an annual true-up.
Often nobody chose it. The inventory app tracks units, not dollars, and the accounts started on a cash basis.
What a year-end true-up does to the numbers
Back to the opening. The dog-bed brand ran all of 2025 at an estimated 37% cost of goods.
| 2025, whole brand | Amount |
|---|---|
| Inventory at cost, January 1 | $850,000 |
| Purchases at landed cost | $3,300,000 |
| Revenue | $8,400,000 |
| Cost of goods booked, 37% of revenue | $3,108,000 |
| Inventory the accounts expected at December 31 | $1,042,000 |
| December 31 count, at landed cost | $968,000 |
| Year-end correction | $74,000 |
The $74,000 lands in December. December revenue was $1,100,000, so cost of goods for the month becomes $407,000 + $74,000 = $481,000, and December's gross margin drops to 56.3% after eleven months reported at 63%. The year's real cost of goods was $3,182,000, a 62.1% gross margin.
That is close to a point of margin, the whole $74,000, that ad budgets, price changes and the spring purchase order were all set against. A lender or buyer reading the monthly P&L sees one bad December and asks a question nobody can answer.
What an annual true-up hides
Margin by channel. Under a percentage-of-sales estimate, a bed sold on Amazon at $119 takes 37%, about $44 of cost, and a bed sold to a pet store at $58 takes about $21, though both cost $40 to land. The wholesale bed looks like it earns $37 of gross profit when it earns $18, so wholesale looks far more profitable than it is. Margin by channel needs every sale to carry its own cost.
Shrink. Units that are stolen, mispicked or miscounted vanish into cost of goods. A monthly count by product shows which products are short; an annual count shows only that something was.
Stock lost at a 3PL or at Amazon. A loss nobody knows about is a claim nobody files. A monthly count against a perpetual record shows which location is short while the trail is fresh enough to chase the 3PL or open a case with Amazon. With one count a year, the loss surfaces up to a year later, if at all.
Write-downs that belong in an earlier month. Stock is carried at cost only while it will sell for at least that much after the costs of selling it. When it becomes clear a product will not, the write-down belongs in that month, whether or not the brand has decided to clear the stock. When cost of goods runs on an estimate, the write-down often waits for the count, and the margin in between was too high. How the entry works is in inventory write-offs and write-downs.
What it takes to run perpetual inventory
Six movements have to reach the record.
Every receipt, at landed cost. When a shipment arrives, the units come in at the factory price plus freight, duty, brokerage and inbound handling. If a freight or duty bill has not arrived by month end, book an estimate for it on that shipment; when the bill comes, the difference for units already sold goes to cost of goods. How to split one container's costs across products is covered in what landed cost is.
Every sale, taking its cost. Cost of goods is recorded when the sale is recorded, which is when the customer takes control of the goods. That usually follows the shipping terms, on the website's terms of sale or the buyer's purchase order. Each order line takes the cost of the units it used, under the costing method chosen with the CPA.
Returns. A returned unit that can be sold again goes back into inventory at the cost it left at, and its cost of goods reverses. A unit that comes back damaged goes back at the lower of the cost it left at and what it can still sell for after any repair and selling costs, or comes off entirely if it cannot be sold. At month end, a brand with meaningful returns also estimates returns still to come on recent sales, holds back that revenue, and holds back the cost of the units it expects to get back.
Transfers. Moving 1,000 beds from the 3PL to Amazon changes where the stock is, not how much there is. The record has to follow it so each location's count can be checked. Freight to get stock into Amazon is commonly added to its cost; some CPAs expense a move between the brand's own locations. Either is acceptable if applied the same way every time.
Bundles and kits. Building a bundle takes its components out of stock, and selling one takes the components' cost. If the record sells a bed-and-cover bundle without relieving the parts, it still shows the bed and the cover on the shelf after both have shipped.
Adjustments. Lost, damaged and miscounted units come off inventory when the loss happens, or when it is found if the date cannot be known. Any reimbursement is booked separately once it is approved or payment is probable. Each adjustment is a journal entry with a reason, so a pattern shows over months.
Why a count is still needed under perpetual
A perpetual record says what should be on the shelf. Only a count says what is. Receiving errors, mispicks, theft and a 3PL's own mistakes all make the record drift.
Under periodic, the count creates cost of goods. Under perpetual, it checks the record, and any difference is corrected through an adjustment in the month it is found. Many brands cycle count, a few products each week, with fast sellers and expensive ones counted most often. An auditor will usually want to watch a count at or near year end; with reliable cycle counts it can be at another date, and stock at a 3PL or Amazon is usually confirmed with them. A lender with stock in its borrowing base may also ask for counts or inspections.
Compare count and record product by product, not only in total, because overs and unders on different products cancel in dollars. How to measure that match rate is in inventory accuracy, and ecommerce inventory management covers working a mismatch location by location.
How to move from periodic to perpetual without redoing the year
Switching does not mean restating closed months. The switch starts on a date, and the record is right from that date forward.
- Pick a cutover date at the start of a quiet month. Avoid the weeks before Black Friday and the days a container is arriving.
- Count everything on that date. Count what you hold, have the 3PL count on the same date, and take Amazon's inventory report for that date, plus anything in transit the brand already owns.
- Value the count at landed cost per unit. Use the latest purchase orders plus the freight and duty bills for each shipment. Where several shipments are still on hand at different costs, the costing method decides how they layer; settle FIFO or weighted average with the CPA now.
- Book one adjustment in the last periodic month. The difference between the book inventory balance and the counted value goes through cost of goods in the month before cutover. That is the year-end true-up, taken early. Anything in the difference that has another home, such as money a supplier owes or a write-down, is booked there. If the gap began before the last year end, or the switch also changes the costing method, the CPA decides whether it corrects the prior year and whether the IRS needs to approve the change.
- From the cutover date, record every movement. Receipts at landed cost, sales with their cost, returns, transfers and adjustments, as above.
- Count again at the end of the first month. Expect a bigger difference than later; the first month finds the gaps in receiving.
Many brands and their CPAs still prefer January 1, so the whole year reads one way. A mid-year cutover works too: the year's P&L is periodic before the date and perpetual after it, the one adjustment explains the join, and a note in the year-end accounts covers it.
Which system a brand can actually run
A small catalog in one warehouse, counted product by product every month, can run periodic and know its margins. Once stock sits in more than one place, sells through more than one channel, or margin by product starts deciding which products to keep, perpetual tells the CEO what the business is earning while there is still time to act.
One question settles where a brand stands today. If this month's cost of goods is a percentage, it will learn its real margin at the next count. If it is a cost per unit from a table, times units sold, with the balance trued up at a count, it is in between: product margins look right, but losses, short shipments and cost changes still wait for the count. If it is the landed cost of the units that shipped, plus any losses found, it is perpetual. How inventory moves from container to cost of goods is in inventory accounting for ecommerce.
FAQ
What is the difference between perpetual and periodic inventory?
Perpetual inventory updates the inventory balance and cost of goods sold with every receipt, sale, return and adjustment, and uses counts to check the record. Periodic inventory updates them at each count, working out cost of goods as beginning inventory plus purchases less ending inventory. Perpetual books lost units separately from units sold once a count or a claim finds them; periodic folds them into cost of goods.
Which is better for an ecommerce brand, perpetual or periodic inventory?
It depends on the setup. A brand with a small catalog in one warehouse that counts every product monthly can run periodic well. Once stock sits in several places, such as a 3PL and Amazon, or sells through several channels, perpetual gives margin by channel every month and shows lost stock while it can still be claimed.
Can a brand switch from periodic to perpetual inventory mid-year?
Yes, without restating closed months. Pick a cutover date at the start of a quiet month, count all stock at every location, value it at landed cost, and book one adjustment in the last periodic month to bring inventory to the count. From the cutover date, record every receipt, sale, return, transfer and adjustment as it happens.



