A cookware brand ships its largest wholesale account, a home-goods chain, 96 percent of the pans it ordered in October, and the chain's scorecard marks it at 75 percent. Both figures are fill rate, counted two ways, and the chain charges on the lower one. Six weeks later the payment arrives short. The brand is a worked example with its numbers set out below. Priced in full, the short ship cost it about $5,400 for the month, and the fines were under $500 of that.
Fill rate is the share of what a customer ordered that a supplier shipped complete on the first shipment. Measured in units, it is units shipped divided by units ordered. Measured in orders, it is the share of purchase orders shipped with every line complete. Retailers that score suppliers on it can charge the ones that miss.
What is fill rate?
For a brand selling wholesale, the customer is the chain or distributor, and the order is a purchase order with several lines, one line per product. A pan that ships two weeks late on a second truck does not count toward fill rate. Neither does a line the buyer cancels because it arrived short.
The number matters in two places. Operations uses it to see whether stock, the 3PL and supplier lead times are keeping up with demand. Finance sees it later, in the remittance, as money invoiced and not received. The guide to inventory KPIs covers fill rate as an operations measure next to stockout rate.
The fill rate formula, three ways
Each divides by something different, so each answers a different question.
| Measure | Formula | What it answers |
|---|---|---|
| Unit fill rate | Units shipped ÷ units ordered × 100 | How much of the volume went out? |
| Line fill rate | Lines shipped complete ÷ lines ordered × 100 | How many products did the buyer get in full? |
| Order fill rate | Orders shipped complete ÷ orders received × 100 | How many purchase orders arrived with nothing missing? |
A large order shipped 95 percent complete scores 95 on units and zero on orders. In this example unit fill is the highest and order fill the lowest, but that order is not fixed: when one large order falls short and many small ones ship complete, unit fill can be the lowest of the three. A brand that reads only its unit fill rate can believe it is serving a chain well while the chain's buyer, reading order fill rate, sees a supplier that fails one order in four.
The one to track is the measure the chain's vendor agreement scores, counted its way: units, cases or dollars.
One month of shipments, three fill rates
The cookware brand sells cast-iron and enamel pans: $3.15 million a year on Amazon, $1.75 million on its Shopify store and $2.1 million wholesale, $7 million in all. Wholesale is about $175,000 a month: roughly $144,000 to the home-goods chain, which sends its purchase orders through EDI, system to system, and about $31,000 to some 200 independent kitchen shops. The pans come from a factory in China, and a 3PL ships the wholesale orders.
The chain pays $24 a pan. Each pan costs the brand $11 landed, including freight and duty, so the brand makes $13 of gross margin on each one.
In October the chain sends 20 purchase orders covering 300 lines and 6,000 pans, worth $144,000. A container ran three weeks late, so the 3PL ships 5,760 pans. The 240 missing pans fall on 21 lines, and those 21 lines fall on 5 of the 20 orders.
| October at the chain | Figure |
|---|---|
| Pans ordered | 6,000 ($144,000) |
| Pans shipped | 5,760 |
| Unit fill rate | 5,760 ÷ 6,000 = 96% |
| Line fill rate | 279 of 300 lines complete = 93% |
| Order fill rate | 15 of 20 orders complete = 75% |
| Fill rate charge, illustrative, $99 on each short order (5 orders) | $495 |
| Gross margin on 240 cancelled pans | $3,120 |
| Other compliance deductions (late ship notice, label errors) | $1,800 |
| Cost of the month's short ship | $5,415 |
| If every month went like October, for a year | $64,980 |
| Share of $2.1M wholesale revenue | 3.1% |
The warehouse sees 96 percent and thinks October went well. The chain sees 75 percent from the same trucks.
Fill rate vs OTIF
OTIF stands for on time, in full. It adds the delivery window to fill rate: an order passes only if every line arrives complete and it arrives inside the window the buyer set. Fill rate asks whether the order was complete. OTIF asks whether it was complete and on time.
That makes OTIF stricter than order fill rate. In the cookware example, the five short orders fail OTIF no matter when they arrive, and any of the other fifteen that reached the chain's warehouse a day late fail too.
Some large retailers publish their own OTIF or fill rate programs in their supplier manuals, with a target, a measurement window and a charge for falling short, set as a fee per failed order or a percentage of the value of the goods that missed. The terms differ by retailer and change over time, so the only version that counts is the one in the brand's own vendor agreement and compliance manual, reread whenever the retailer updates it.
What is a good fill rate?
A published fill rate benchmark is only useful if it says what it counts: units, lines or orders, and whether backorders shipped later are included. A unit fill rate and an order fill rate for the same shipments can sit twenty points apart, as the October table shows.
Two comparisons are more useful. The first is the target in the retailer's vendor agreement, measured the retailer's way, because that is the one that triggers charges. The second is the brand's own trend, month by month and by account. A fill rate that drops with every marketplace promotion says something about how stock is allocated.
What a short ship costs a wholesale brand
For the cookware brand, the fine is $495 of a $5,415 month, about 9 percent of the cost. The rest comes from two places that do not arrive labelled as a fill rate problem.
The cancelled units. Whether a chain cancels short units or holds them as a backorder is set in its vendor agreement. When it cancels, the sale is gone. The brand loses $5,760 of revenue and the $3,120 of gross margin that came with it, six times the fine.
The deductions that ride along. The same rushed week that sent incomplete orders also produced a late ship notice (the advance ship notice, or ASN, that tells the chain what is on the truck) and a few mislabeled cartons. Those are separate retail chargebacks, each with its own code in the remittance, and here they add $1,800.
Every loss here is counted at the $13 gross margin per pan; wholesale costs that move with each pan, such as commissions and outbound freight, would make each one somewhat smaller. If every month went like October, the short ships would cost about $65,000 a year, about 3 percent of wholesale revenue. To put that against the channel's profit, assume wholesale clears 10 cents of operating profit on each dollar after trade spend, rep commissions, outbound freight, the 3PL, the wholesale team and its share of overhead. That assumption is for illustration only. On it, the short ships take almost a third of what the channel earns.
There is a slower cost too. A chain that keeps a scorecard can use it when deciding how much to order next season and how much shelf space a supplier keeps. That cost does not appear in any month's results.
How to book retailer deductions
Deductions arrive with the payment: a remittance smaller than the invoice, with a list of codes explaining the gap. What the bookkeeper does with that gap decides whether the wholesale channel's profit is reported correctly.
The first habit that hides it leaves the unpaid balance sitting in accounts receivable, where it looks like a slow payer. The receivables aging grows, days sales outstanding creeps up, and nobody notices that the money is never coming. The second writes the balance off as bad debt. That clears receivables but files a price cut as a credit loss, so the channel's sales look higher than they were and its margin looks better. Where nobody owns the scorecard, deductions can sit in receivables for quarters.
The fix is to book deductions by type and take them off wholesale revenue, unless a deduction pays for a distinct service from the retailer at its fair value, which is an expense. Finance teams call this gross to net: the invoice is the gross figure, and each deduction steps it down to what the brand keeps.
| Deduction type | Where it goes |
|---|---|
| Compliance fines and chargebacks (fill rate, OTIF, ship notice, labels) | Against wholesale revenue, on their own line |
| Trade promotions and markdown allowances | Against wholesale revenue, on their own line |
| Returns and damage allowances | Against wholesale revenue, on their own line |
| Shortage claims the brand believes are wrong | Stays in receivables while disputed, less a reserve, taken off revenue, for the share the brand's dispute history says it will not recover |
Deductions the brand expects, from its history with each retailer, are estimated and taken off revenue in the month of the sale, including ones not yet on a remittance. Bad debt is an amount the buyer cannot pay, not one it chose to deduct. The guide to order to cash follows one wholesale invoice through payment and shows the entries for each kind of deduction.
Some deductions are wrong. A shortage claim on a carton the carrier's proof of delivery shows arriving, or a fine for a ship notice that went out on time, can be disputed. A vendor agreement may set a deadline for disputes, and the brand finds its own in the compliance manual. A dispute is a claim with evidence attached, and the retailer decides it.
The monthly test: wholesale receivables tie to invoices, less cash received, less deductions booked, with every open deduction listed, coded and dated.
Holding stock back for a marketplace event
Now suppose October's shortfall had been a choice: the same 240 pans held back for an Amazon event, because each pan earns more there. That choice can be priced before it is made.
Holding a pan back gives up the $13 of wholesale margin. Counting all of October's compliance deductions against the short ship, it also triggers about $9.56 of charges per pan ($2,295 across 240 pans), so the pan has to earn more than $22.56 on Amazon after its unit cost, Amazon's fees and the advertising spent to sell it. On the fines alone, the hurdle is about $15.06 a pan. Either way, the measure is contribution margin, the profit a unit leaves after every cost that moves with it.
Suppose the pans sell on Amazon for $45 and Amazon's fees plus advertising come to $20 a pan. After the $11 unit cost, each pan contributes $14, and the 240 pans earn $3,360. Shipped to the chain, they would have earned $3,120 of margin and avoided $2,295 of charges, a swing of $5,415. Holding them back cost the brand $2,055 for the month before any damage to the scorecard, and about $255 even if only the fines are counted.
Two more questions sharpen the answer. If the pans would have sold on Amazon a few weeks later at full price anyway, the event moved the sale forward rather than adding one. And the fair comparison is contribution on both sides: taking wholesale's per-pan commission and freight off the $13 narrows the $2,055. The contribution margin vs gross margin guide shows how to build that per-unit view by channel.
The decision belongs to whoever runs operations and whoever runs finance, together. Operations knows what the stock can cover; finance knows what each choice does to margin and cash.
Who owns fill rate, and what finance owns
Fill rate is an operations number. It moves with supplier lead time, with stock held back for other channels and with the 3PL's picking accuracy. Finance cannot prevent a short ship. What it owns is the price of each one and the record of what was deducted, so the fill rate discussion is about dollars rather than percentages. The guide to stockout cost covers the related cost of running out entirely, where no order is placed at all.
On the warehouse report, October looked like a 96 percent month. Priced in full it cost about $5,400 under these assumptions, and the fine was the smallest line.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between fill rate and OTIF?
Fill rate measures whether an order shipped complete. OTIF, on time and in full, measures whether it arrived complete and inside the delivery window the buyer set. An order that ships complete but arrives a day late passes fill rate and fails OTIF. Because a late arrival also fails an order, a supplier's OTIF score can never be higher than its order fill rate for the same orders.
How should retail chargebacks be recorded?
Retail chargebacks the brand accepts, or expects from its history with the retailer, are taken off wholesale revenue, each type on its own line, in the month of the sale. They are not bad debt, which is an amount the buyer cannot pay. A chargeback the brand disputes stays in receivables, less a reserve taken off revenue for the share its dispute history says it will not recover.



