A 40-store gift chain offers to put your candles in every store, 100 a store, on one condition: you manage the stock, and it pays each month for what sold. In the example used here, a chain buying outright would order about 800 candles at a time and pay each $14,400 invoice in 60 days. Say yes to these terms instead and you fund all 4,000 candles on its shelves, $26,000 at cost, about $20,800 more of your money in stock than the outright deal under these assumptions.
Half of that offer is vendor managed inventory, or VMI: the supplier, not the buyer, decides when and how much to ship to keep the buyer stocked. VMI decides who replenishes, which sets how much stock sits at the buyer and when each invoice lands. Consignment decides who owns that stock until it sells, and so whether you are paid after delivery or only after the sale. They often arrive in one offer, but they are different negotiations, and each moves your cash in its own way.
What is vendor managed inventory (VMI)?
Under VMI the vendor watches the buyer's stock and decides when to replenish it and by how much, within limits the two sides agree. The buyer stops sending a purchase order for each restock and shares its stock and sales data instead, usually weekly or daily.
A VMI program usually runs in four steps:
- The buyer and vendor agree on products, locations, the minimum and maximum stock at each, and how data is shared.
- The buyer sends the vendor its on-hand stock and sales by product and location.
- The vendor decides what to ship and ships it, often against a standing order.
- The buyer pays, either for each shipment on delivery or for what it sold or used, depending on the agreement.
Step 4 is where two very different deals hide under one name. In ordinary VMI, the buyer owns each shipment when it arrives and pays on its normal terms. In consignment-style VMI, the vendor still owns the stock sitting at the buyer's site and is paid only when the buyer sells or uses it. Some large buyers ask for the second and call it the first. In grocery and drug chains the second version is often called scan-based trading or pay-on-scan: the brand is paid only for what scans at the register.
A simple vendor managed inventory example
A regional pharmacy chain carries a skincare brand's cleanser in 25 stores. It used to send a purchase order each month, and stores ran out between orders. Under VMI, the chain sends the brand a file every Monday with units on hand and units sold at each store. The brand's operations lead decides what each store needs and ships it within the minimum and maximum the chain set. The chain owns each carton when it is received and pays the brand's invoice on net 45.
For the accounting, nothing has changed. It is still a wholesale sale, counted when the cartons are delivered, with the invoice in accounts receivable until the chain pays. Only the planning, and with it the timing of each invoice, has moved.
Change one term, so that the chain pays only for what sells through its registers, and the same program most likely becomes a consignment arrangement, though the agreement as a whole decides. The rest of this guide is mostly about that one term.
Vendor managed inventory vs consignment
Because one term covers replenishment and the other ownership, a deal can be VMI without consignment, consignment without VMI, or both at once.
| Ordinary VMI | Consignment (with or without VMI) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides when to restock | The vendor | The vendor under VMI; otherwise the buyer requests stock |
| Who owns stock at the buyer's site | The buyer, from delivery | The vendor, until the buyer sells or uses it |
| When the vendor counts the sale | At delivery | When the buyer sells or uses the goods |
| When the vendor is paid | On the invoice terms, from delivery | On a schedule after each sale, often monthly |
| Who bears loss, theft and damage at the buyer's site | The buyer | Usually the vendor, unless the agreement says otherwise |
| Who carries unsold stock | The buyer, unless it negotiated returns | The vendor; unsold goods come back or are written off |
Tax rules draw the same line. IRS guidance says a business includes "goods out on consignment" in its inventory and excludes "goods consigned to you" (IRS Publication 538). The financial statements follow the same idea, though there the test is who controls the goods, not only who holds title.
Benefits and risks of vendor managed inventory
For the buyer, VMI is mostly upside: the vendor does the planning, and under consignment terms the vendor also carries the stock.
For a brand on the vendor side, the benefits are real but narrower:
- Better shelf presence. A brand that manages the restock keeps its own products in stock.
- Sell-through data. Weekly store-level sales show which products and locations move.
- Smoother production, for a brand that makes its own product. Shipping to steady sales rather than lumpy purchase orders makes runs easier to plan.
The risks sit mostly with the vendor:
- Cash tied up longer. Under consignment terms, the vendor pays for the goods and waits for them to sell before it is paid.
- Stock it cannot see. Units at 40 stores are counted by the buyer's staff, not the brand's.
- Loss and damage. Unless the agreement shifts it to the buyer, theft and breakage at the stores is the brand's loss.
- Slow and unsold stock. If a product stalls, it is still the brand's, and it may come back months later in worse condition.
- Bankruptcy. If the chain fails with consigned stock on its shelves, the brand can struggle to get it back.
- Out-of-stock penalties. Once the brand manages the shelf, empty shelves are its fault, and some large buyers fine vendors for missed in-stock targets.
When the brand is the vendor: VMI with a wholesale buyer
Most consumer brands meet VMI from this side first: a chain or distributor offers a bigger placement if you manage the stock. Four questions decide whether the offer is good business.
Who owns the stock, and when does ownership pass?
The agreement decides. Look for the clause on title and risk of loss, and for the payment trigger. If the buyer is invoiced and owes payment when goods arrive, ownership has almost certainly passed at delivery, and this is ordinary VMI. If the buyer pays only for units it reports as sold, or the brand can call stock back or send it to another account, the brand most likely still owns those goods for accounting and has no sale yet. A buyer that owes for everything it received but may send unsold units back has bought them; the brand books the sale less the returns it expects.
When can the brand count the sale?
Under ordinary VMI, the sale counts at delivery, the same as any wholesale order, and the cost of the units moves to cost of goods sold in the same month. If the buyer can return unsold stock or claim markdown money, the brand books the sale less what it expects to give back.
Under consignment the chain has not bought anything yet. Until a candle rings up at its register, it is still your candle, and your cash, sitting on the chain's shelf. The units stay on the brand's balance sheet as inventory, at their cost, until the buyer sells them. Only then does the brand record revenue and the matching cost of goods. Shipping 4,000 units to a consignment buyer is a move of the brand's own stock from one location to another, not $72,000 of sales.
Because many agreements mix terms, have the brand's CPA read it before the first shipment. Booking a consignment shipment as a sale overstates revenue, margin and receivables, and the correction usually surfaces at the worst time, during a lender's review or an investor's diligence.
What it does to cash: a worked example
Take the candle company from the opening; the company and its figures are illustrative. Each candle sells for $36 on its own Shopify store. The chain's wholesale price is $18, half of that. The landed cost of each candle, the factory price plus freight, duty and receiving, is $6.50. That gives a wholesale gross margin of 63.9 percent.
The chain wants 100 candles in each of its 40 stores, 4,000 in all, and expects to sell about 800 a month across the chain. That opening fill is five months of stock, and the depth is what pushes the chain to ask for consignment. The company compares two versions of the deal.
Selling outright. A chain buying outright orders about a month at a time: 800 candles, 20 a store, on net 60, then about 800 more each month as they sell. Each order is a $14,400 invoice. The company books $14,400 of revenue and $5,200 of cost of goods on delivery and collects 60 days later. Five orders, 4,000 candles, bring in $72,000 of revenue and $46,000 of gross profit, all collected by day 180.
Consignment-style VMI. The company ships all 4,000 candles at once but keeps ownership. The chain reports sales at each month end and pays for them 30 days later. It bears loss at the stores, and over the five months 80 candles, 2 percent, go missing or arrive broken. The table follows the opening 4,000 candles until they have sold; restocking comes after it.
| Month | Candles sold | Revenue booked | Paid on day | Cash collected to date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 800 | $14,400 | 60 | $14,400 |
| 2 | 800 | $14,400 | 90 | $28,800 |
| 3 | 800 | $14,400 | 120 | $43,200 |
| 4 | 800 | $14,400 | 150 | $57,600 |
| 5 | 720 | $12,960 | 180 | $70,560 |
Collections run on almost the same calendar: under either deal about $14,400 arrives each month from day 60. The difference is what the company has to put on the chain's shelves first. Outright, at most about 800 candles, $5,200 at cost, sit at the chain, and they are the chain's. Under consignment, 4,000 candles, $26,000 at cost, sit there, and they are the company's. The chain's depth costs it $20,800 of extra stock, and those 3,200 extra candles cannot be sold on Shopify, on Amazon or to another account while they wait.
The profit is lower too. Over the five months the company books $70,560 of revenue and $25,480 of cost of goods. The 80 lost candles are the company's loss: their $520 of cost is expensed, and the $1,440 they would have sold for never arrives. In practice the 80 rarely come with an explanation. The chain may confirm one broken carton and have no record of the rest, and the untraced remainder is written off all the same. Gross profit after the loss is $44,560, against $46,000 outright.
The gap does not close after the first five months. As candles sell, the company ships more to keep each store near 100, so while the account runs about $26,000 of its stock sits on the chain's shelves, against about $5,200 of the chain's own stock under an outright deal. The $26,000 comes back only when the account ends and the unsold stock is returned or paid for. And if the candle sells half as fast, outright orders simply shrink, while under consignment the same $26,000 sits twice as long and the company is paid half as much each month.
For a company with a modest wholesale book, that extra $20,800 or so can decide whether the next factory deposit is paid from cash or from a credit line. The guide to the cash conversion cycle shows how days in inventory and days to collect add up, and a consignment account stretches the first. Holding that extra stock also has a cost of its own, covered in the post on inventory carrying cost.
None of this makes the deal bad. A 40-store placement can be worth $20,800 of extra working capital. But price it on the real cash timeline, and ask for a higher wholesale price or better terms for carrying the stock.
Stock at someone else's site still has to be counted
Consigned stock is still your inventory, so it belongs in your records by location, and it has to be counted. The buyer's weekly file is a report, not a count. Ask for the right to count the stock, or for a periodic count signed off by the buyer, and compare it with what you shipped minus what the buyer reported sold.
Differences are usually theft, breakage or units sold but not reported. When stock is lost or damaged, the cost is expensed in the month the loss happens, or the month it is found when the date cannot be known, as with shrink found by a count. It is not spread across the units that remain. The guide to inventory KPIs shows how to track the count against the books each month. When stock at the buyer's site will sell for less than it cost, after the costs of selling it, because it is dated, shopworn or discontinued, it is written down to that lower amount. The guide to inventory accounting for ecommerce covers write-downs and costing methods in more depth.
Questions to settle in the agreement before saying yes
Before signing a VMI or consignment agreement with a wholesale buyer, get written answers to these:
- When does ownership pass to the buyer: on delivery, on sale, or on use?
- When are you paid, and against what report? How soon after each month end?
- Who bears loss, theft and damage at the buyer's stores and warehouse, and whose insurance covers the stock while it sits there?
- Can the buyer return unsold stock? If so, until when, in what condition, and who pays the freight?
- What happens to the stock at the buyer's site if either side ends the agreement?
- What data does the buyer share, how often, and do you have the right to count the stock?
- Who sets the minimum and maximum stock at each location, and can the buyer change them without notice?
- Can the buyer take deductions from its payments for shortages, markdowns or promotions, and on what evidence? The guide to wholesale order to cash shows how deductions come off a payment.
- If the buyer goes bankrupt, can you get your stock back? Consigned goods can be swept up with the buyer's own inventory unless the paperwork protects them, so have a lawyer read that clause and say what filing is needed before the first shipment.
Then have your CPA read the final draft for the ownership and payment terms, since those decide how every shipment is recorded.
When the brand is the customer: VMI from a packaging supplier
The same arrangement runs the other way when your own suppliers offer to manage your stock. Packaging is the common case. Usually the printer runs a large batch of your mailers or labels at the lower unit price, holds it in its own warehouse, and bills as it ships cartons to your 3PL, on condition you take the whole run within an agreed window. Less often, the supplier keeps a supply at the 3PL and refills it as it is used.
Here you are the buyer, and the same question decides the accounting: when do you own the stock?
- If you own each delivery on arrival and pay on the supplier's terms, this is ordinary VMI. The boxes are your inventory or supplies from delivery, and the bill is due on its terms. You gain the planning help and give up control of how much arrives.
- If you pay only for what you pull from the supply, the stock is consigned to you. It usually stays off your books until it is used, and you pay for each pull.
Take an illustrative brand that uses 20,000 printed mailer boxes a quarter at $0.80 each. Buying them outright means $16,000 paid for a quarter's supply up front, or more if the printer's minimum run is larger. Under a consignment arrangement, the brand pays about $5,300 a month as it uses them, so most of that $16,000 stays in the bank until the boxes ship with orders.
The cost is usually hidden in three places. The price per box may be higher to pay for the service. There may be a minimum you commit to use. And printed packaging is worthless to anyone else, so printers commonly require the customer to buy whatever is left when the design changes or the agreement ends. If a rebrand is planned in six months, that promise becomes a bill for boxes it cannot use. The cost belongs in the books when the rebrand is decided and it is clear the boxes will go unused, not when the supplier's invoice arrives. The accountant should also check whether a large commitment needs a note in the financial statements before then.
Stock you do not own also has to stay out of your count. If the 3PL's stock report lists the supplier's consigned boxes beside your own products, your inventory can be overstated at year end. Ask the 3PL to keep consigned items on a separate line.
How to decide on a VMI offer
Negotiate the two parts separately. Agreeing to manage a buyer's replenishment is mainly a planning commitment, though it also sets how much stock you ship and when you invoice, and it can be worth giving for a bigger placement. Agreeing to own the stock until it sells is a financing commitment, and it should be priced like one.
For a wholesale offer, work out three numbers before saying yes: the stock you will keep at the buyer's site at cost, the days between shipping a unit and being paid for it, and the loss rate you will bear. Then set that stock beside the next production run and the stock already held for Shopify, Amazon and other wholesale accounts; the guide to ecommerce inventory management covers how much cash sits in stock across locations. For a supplier's offer, the test runs the other way: the cash it keeps in your bank, against what you pay in price, minimums and leftover stock.
FAQ
What is the difference between VMI and consignment?
VMI decides who plans the restock: the vendor does. Consignment decides who owns the stock at the buyer's site: the vendor does, until the buyer sells or uses it. A deal can be either or both. Under ordinary VMI the sale counts at delivery; under consignment it counts only when the goods sell.
Does vendor managed inventory help a brand's cash flow?
It depends on which side the brand is on. As the customer of a consignment supplier, the brand pays only as it uses the stock, so cash stays in the bank longer. As the vendor to a consignment buyer, the brand pays for the goods first and is paid only after they sell, so more cash stays tied up.



