By October 31, a cast-iron cookware company had collected about $71,000 from five weeks of orders for a skillet it had run out of, yet its P&L showed only $28,000 of sales from them, and it still owed customers about $46,000 in skillets or refunds. The company is our example, and so are its figures.
That gap is what a backorder is. A backorder is an order a customer places while the product is out of stock, on the promise that it ships when new stock arrives. Some stores charge at checkout, as the company here does; others charge when the order ships. Backorder management is deciding when to take those orders, what to tell the customers, and how to treat their money until the goods ship. Money taken for a backorder is owed to the customer until the box ships, as goods or as a refund. It is not sales, and what leaves the bank to settle it is the cost of getting the order out, or the refund.
Backorder vs out of stock vs preorder
| What the customer sees | What happens to the order | Cash | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Out of stock | "Sold out" or an unavailable listing, maybe a back-in-stock email signup | No order is taken | None comes in |
| Backorder | The product is for sale with a later ship date | Order taken now, shipped when stock lands | Collected now if charged at checkout, owed to the customer until shipment |
| Preorder | A product not yet released, for sale before launch | Order taken now, shipped at launch | Collected now if charged at checkout, owed to the customer until shipment |
The difference between a backorder and a preorder is the product's history: a backorder is a product you normally keep in stock and have run out of; a preorder is one that has never shipped. The accounting is the same for both. The difference between a backorder and going out of stock is a choice, and it is mostly a cash and customer choice.
When taking backorders makes sense
Taking backorders makes sense when four things are true:
- The arrival date is firm. The goods are on a named vessel or truck with a date from the freight forwarder, not a factory estimate. Supplier lead time is where most broken ship dates start.
- The customer will wait. A replacement skillet can wait five weeks. A gift for a fixed date, or anything seasonal, usually cannot.
- The margin covers the extra work. Delay emails, customer service time and cancellations all cost money that a normal order does not.
- You can refund everyone if the date slips. If the cash has already been spent, a slip becomes a cash problem as well as a customer one.
When any of the four is shaky, going out of stock with a back-in-stock signup is often the safer choice. No cash comes in, but nothing is owed either.
What a backordered order is in the accounts
A sale is recorded when the customer takes control of the goods, which for most online orders is when they ship (or when they arrive, if your terms say the customer owns them on delivery). Cash received before that is not revenue. It is money owed to the customer, usually held in an account called customer deposits or unearned revenue, a liability on the balance sheet.
Here is one $140 skillet ordered on backorder, at an example processing rate of 3% (your rate is on your payment provider's statement). Sales tax is left out for clarity: it is collected for the state and kept out of sales, and it goes back to the customer with the refund if the order is cancelled.
| Event | Cash | Owed to customers | Revenue | Cost of goods | Inventory | Processing fees |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Customer pays at checkout | +$135.80 | +$140.00 | +$4.20 | |||
| Skillet ships from the 3PL | −$140.00 | +$140.00 | +$42.00 | −$42.00 | ||
| Or: customer cancels before it ships | −$140.00 | −$140.00 | (stays) |
Three things in that table catch people out.
Revenue and cost arrive together. The $140 becomes revenue on the day the skillet ships, and its $42 landed cost (the factory price plus freight and duty) moves from inventory to cost of goods sold the same day. Until then, neither appears on the P&L. The usual estimate for returns applies to these sales like any other, taken off when the sale is booked.
The fee on a cancelled order is not returned. On Shopify Payments, Shopify's refund page says, at the time of writing, that credit card fees are not refunded when you refund or cancel an order. Other providers set their own terms, so check yours. The fee becomes a cost of an order that never turned into a sale. Expensing processing fees when they are charged is the usual treatment, including on orders not yet shipped. Holding them back as an asset is unusual, and if your CPA does it, the fee on any cancelled order is expensed then.
The inventory count goes negative; the inventory account does not. If your store keeps selling at zero stock, its count drops below zero, by several hundred units in this example. That is a list of open orders, not stock. The inventory account holds only goods you own, valued at cost.
For how an ordinary order moves from checkout to shipment to payout, see order to cash for ecommerce. A backorder is the same path with a gap of weeks between the first two steps.
One backordered skillet, followed for three months
The company sells about $4 million a year, and its 12-inch skillet is the best seller. The skillet sold out on its own store on September 22, four weeks before a container of 2,400 was due at the 3PL on October 20. Rather than show "sold out", the company kept selling it with "Ships by October 31" on the product page, at the usual $140. The container then slipped eight days, and the company stopped taking backorders on October 26, once the new arrival date was confirmed.
The container landed on October 28. The 3PL shipped the oldest 200 orders by October 31 and the rest by November 6. Because 360 orders would now ship after the promised date, the company emailed those customers on October 27 with a new date of November 7 and the choice to cancel for a full refund. Across the wait, 72 customers cancelled: 40 on their own and 32 of the 360 after the email.
| September | October | November | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Backorders taken | 140 ($19,600) | 460 ($64,400) | none |
| Cancelled and refunded | none | 72 ($10,080) | none |
| Shipped | none | 200 | 328 |
| Revenue from backorders | $0 | $28,000 | $45,920 |
| Cost of goods | $0 | $8,400 | $13,776 |
| Processing fees, 3% | $588 | $1,932 | $0 |
| Net cash in from backorders | $19,012 | $52,388 | $0 |
| Owed to customers at month end | $19,600 | $45,920 | $0 |
Check the October owed figure: $19,600 + $64,400 − $10,080 refunded − $28,000 shipped = $45,920, which is 328 open orders at $140.
How the bank and the P&L looked during the gap
At September 30 the bank had about $19,000 more than it would have, and the P&L showed none of it as sales, only the fees. At October 31 the bank held about $71,000 from these orders. Of that, about $46,000 was owed back as skillets or refunds. October's sales from the skillet were $28,000, below a normal month, and November's were above one.
A CEO who sees $71,000 of new cash in October and a strong order count can spend it on the next ad push or a deposit on another product. Had the container slipped past November 7 as well, the company planned to ask again and refund every customer who did not reply, out of cash that might already have been gone.
The same orders booked from payouts
Some companies record sales when the money lands. On backorders that moves revenue into the months the cash arrived, while the cost of goods still lands when the skillets ship.
| Gross profit from backorders | September | October | November | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue booked when cash arrives | $19,600 | $54,320 | $0 | $73,920 |
| Cost of goods, when the skillets ship | $0 | $8,400 | $13,776 | $22,176 |
| Gross profit, booked from payouts | $19,600 | $45,920 | −$13,776 | $51,744 |
| Gross profit, booked at shipment | $0 | $19,600 | $32,144 | $51,744 |
The three-month total is the same. The months are not: September shows a 100% margin on these orders and November a loss. Any decision taken on September's margin is taken on a number that was never real. The accrual accounting column, booked at shipment, is the one to manage from.
What taking backorders earned
The alternative was five weeks of "sold out". What the backorder path earned depends on how many of these buyers would have come back when the skillet returned. Assume a third of the 600, about 200 orders. That share is the most fragile number here, so put in your own.
Per skillet, contribution margin before ads is $140, less $42 landed cost, $4.20 in fees and $16 to pick, pack and ship, which leaves $77.80.
| Orders kept | Contribution | |
|---|---|---|
| Backorder path: 528 orders at $77.80, less $302 of fees on cancelled orders | 528 | $40,776 |
| Out of stock: one buyer in three comes back | 200 | $15,560 |
| Difference | 328 | $25,216 |
So the backorders were worth about $25,000 of contribution under these assumptions, before the hours spent on delay emails and customer questions. On a second slip, the company would have asked all 328 remaining customers again and refunded anyone who did not reply, and every cancellation costs a fee and earns nothing.
One number stays out of reach. "Ships by October 31" converts worse than "In stock", and how many shoppers saw that date and bought elsewhere does not appear anywhere in the accounts. The comparison above counts only the orders that came in.
Backorders by channel
Your own store
On your own store, whether to take backorders is your call, once a lawyer has checked your wording against the federal rule below. Shopify, for example, lets you keep selling when out of stock with a setting on each product or variant. Put the ship date on the product page and in the order confirmation, because that stated date is the promise customers will hold you to, and only state a date you have good reason to meet. Tell your 3PL before you switch it on. Some warehouse systems hold or reject orders with no stock behind them, and you want them held in date order.
Amazon and eBay
Many brands that sell through Amazon's warehouses do not take backorders there; the listing runs out until new stock is checked in, and stockout cost covers what that gap costs. On orders you ship yourself, the marketplace's rules also set whether you can take the order and how long you have to ship it. Those rules change, so read the current ones in Seller Central or your eBay account first. The accounting is the same as on your own store: nothing is revenue until the order ships. The marketplace pays out on its own schedule, so the cash may not arrive before the sale either.
Wholesale
In wholesale, a backorder usually starts as a short ship. A chain of kitchen stores orders 240 skillets at $66. The company has 120 on hand, so it ships 120 and backorders the other 120 to follow when the container lands.
The first 120 are invoiced on shipment: $7,920 of revenue and a receivable on the buyer's payment terms. The backordered 120 are nothing in the accounts yet. No cash came in, so there is no deposit to hold, and no receivable until they ship. If the buyer paid a deposit on the full order, the part covering the open line stays owed to the buyer until it ships.
Check the purchase order first. Some larger buyers print "no backorders" on it: ship what you have and the rest of the line is cancelled. Independent stores more often take the balance later. Beyond that, what the buyer may do depends on its purchase order and vendor agreement, and a lawyer should confirm what else applies to business orders. Many purchase orders carry a cancel date, after which the buyer can refuse the late line. Some vendor agreements charge fines for short or late shipments, which come off what the buyer pays; how they are measured and booked is in the guide to fill rate. Ask the buyer in writing whether it wants the backordered line shipped or cancelled, and get the answer before you allocate stock from the container.
What to tell customers, and how long is too long
Tell customers the date before they pay, in plain words, and tell them again the moment it changes.
In the US, a federal rule, the FTC's Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule, sets what a seller must do when it cannot ship when it said it would, including telling the buyer and refunding those who do not agree to wait. States can add their own rules. Read the rule and have a lawyer check your product-page, checkout and email wording before you take backorders. This post is not legal advice.
Beyond what a lawyer tells you the law requires, too long is any wait you cannot date with confidence. The company in the example set one rule for itself: take backorders only up to the date its freight forwarder had confirmed, and stop the day that date became uncertain. Its eight-day slip still cost a delay email to 360 customers and 32 cancellations, even with that rule.
What to check each month while backorders are open
- The owed balance matches the open orders. Customer deposits on the balance sheet should equal open backorders at their prices. At October 31 that was 328 orders at $140, $45,920. A difference means a refund or a shipment was missed.
- The forecast carries what is still to pay, plus a refund case. Shipping settles the $45,920 in skillets, not cash. In the 13-week cash flow forecast, enter what it still costs to get the open orders out (any container balance, duty, freight, the 3PL's pick, pack and postage) on their dates. Then run a second case where the date slips again and, as this company planned, every customer who does not reply is refunded at the full price, and the processing fee is not returned, and check the bank covers those refunds.
- Backorders shown beside sales. A month with a large owed balance will look weak on the P&L and strong the month after. Put the open backorder figure next to sales in the monthly pack so nobody reads the swing as demand.
Charged at checkout, backorders also change how fast orders turn into cash, which is why a company that takes them can run a short or even negative cash conversion cycle for a season. That cash is owed to customers until the box ships. Keep enough of it to get their orders out, or to refund them, before it goes anywhere else.
FAQ
Should you charge for a backorder at checkout or when it ships?
Charging at checkout brings the cash in early but creates a balance owed to customers and a processing fee you may lose on every cancellation. Charging at shipment avoids both, but the card authorization can expire before a long backorder ships, and asking a customer to pay again weeks later loses some orders. With an uncertain date, holding the charge is safer. Either way, check your payment provider's terms on charging before shipment.
Can inventory go negative when you take backorders?
The unit count in your store or inventory system can go below zero, because it nets open orders against stock on hand. The inventory account cannot: it holds only goods you own, at cost. A count of −600 means 600 orders waiting for stock, and the money for them sits in a liability until each order ships and becomes revenue.



