Shopify vs Etsy: Fees Compared
Compare the fee structures of Shopify and Etsy side by side to find which platform gives you better margins.
All calculatorsShopify vs Etsy
Shopify vs Etsy: What's Different?
Shopify and Etsy serve overlapping audiences (creative entrepreneurs and small brands) but with very different models. Shopify charges a monthly subscription ($39-$399) plus payment processing (2.5-2.9% + $0.30 with Shopify Payments). Etsy charges $0.20 per listing, 6.5% transaction fee, 3% + $0.25 payment processing, and potentially 12-15% Offsite Ads fees.
For an operator doing $5,000/month in revenue, Shopify costs approximately $39 + $145-175 in processing = ~$184-214/month total. The same operator on Etsy pays roughly $325 in transaction fees + $150 in processing + listing fees = ~$480+/month, and potentially more with Offsite Ads. At this scale, Shopify is significantly cheaper in platform fees. However, the Shopify operator must independently drive all traffic, which could cost hundreds to thousands in advertising.
The fundamental trade-off is traffic vs. control. Etsy provides a built-in marketplace with 90+ million active buyers searching for handmade and unique products. Shopify provides no built-in traffic but gives you a fully customizable storefront, complete brand control, and ownership of your customer email list. Many successful creative sellers start on Etsy to validate their products and build a following, then expand to Shopify for higher margins and brand building.
Compare Fees on the Same Product
Enter your product details once, see how fees compare on both platforms
Enter Product Details (same product, both platforms)
Shopify
Lower fees+ $39.00/mo subscription (not included in per-sale fees)
Profit
$16.82
56.1% margin
Etsy
Profit
$14.69
49.0% margin
Shopify saves you $2.13 in fees per sale
Estimates are based on item price only. Marketplaces may also apply fees to buyer-paid shipping and tax, and rates vary by category and promotions. Confirm current rates with each marketplace.
Fee Structure Comparison
Which Is Better For...
Best for new sellers with no existing audience
Etsy
Etsy's marketplace brings buyers to you. New sellers can list products and start getting views from Etsy's search and recommendation engine immediately. Building traffic to a brand-new Shopify store from scratch requires marketing expertise and budget that most new sellers don't have yet.
Best for established brands scaling up
Shopify
Once you have a proven product line and marketing channels, Shopify's lower per-transaction costs and unlimited customization help you scale profitably. You own your customer data, can run sophisticated email marketing, and aren't subject to Etsy's policy changes or fee increases.
Best for sellers wanting the lowest platform fees
Shopify
Shopify's flat monthly fee plus ~2.9% processing is cheaper than Etsy's 6.5% + 3% + listing fees at almost any meaningful revenue level. Sellers doing $3,000+/month in revenue will typically pay less in total platform fees on Shopify, even before considering Etsy's Offsite Ads surcharge.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, and it's a popular strategy. Use Etsy for marketplace discovery and Shopify as your branded storefront. Include your Shopify URL on Etsy package inserts to drive repeat customers to your own store. Shopify apps like Etsy Integration allow you to sync inventory across both platforms.
Shopify gives you full control over meta titles, descriptions, URLs, blog content, and site structure, enabling comprehensive SEO strategies. Etsy listings benefit from Etsy's high domain authority but you have limited control over SEO elements. For long-term organic traffic ownership, Shopify is superior. For immediate search visibility, Etsy's domain authority helps.
Yes. Etsy's 6.5% transaction fee applies to the total order amount including shipping charges. So if you sell an item for $30 with $5 shipping, Etsy takes 6.5% of $35. This is worth factoring into your pricing strategy, especially for items with high shipping costs.
Etsy offers very limited customization: a banner image, shop icon, about section, and arrangement of listings. Every Etsy shop looks fundamentally similar. Shopify offers thousands of themes with full HTML/CSS/Liquid customization, allowing you to build a completely unique branded experience.
Shopify provides comprehensive analytics including real-time data, customer behavior tracking, sales attribution, and integration with Google Analytics 4. Etsy's analytics are more basic: traffic sources, listing performance, and search term data. For data-driven sellers, Shopify's analytics are significantly more powerful.
More Fee Comparisons
Fees are only one leak. Our guide to ecommerce accounting covers COGS, settlements, and the P&L that shows what you actually keep per sale.
Sell on MultiplePlatforms?
Futureproof automatically tracks fees across Shopify, Etsy, and every other marketplace. See unified P&L in one dashboard, part of the AI finance team starting at $1,000/month.
14-day trial · all six agents · starting at $1,000/month